Showing posts with label Pakistan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pakistan. Show all posts

Monday, February 4, 2008

Know Your Enemy

Agence France-Presse, on Japan Today (Feb 4, 2008, U.S. strategy toward al-Qaida fatally flawed: analysts):

WASHINGTON — In its ideological struggle against al-Qaida, American anti-terrorist strategy too often overlooks the basic tenets of the infamous Chinese warlord Sun Tzu, namely: know your enemy.

That is the fixed view of leading analysts, who conclude that through ignorance of the enemy it faces, ignorance of its nature, its goals, its strengths and its weaknesses, the United States is condemned to failure.

"The attention of the U.S. military and intelligence community is directed almost uniformly toward hunting down militant leaders or protecting U.S. forces, and not toward understanding the enemy we now face," said Bruce Hoffman, a professor at Georgetown University, Washington DC.

"This is a monumental failing not only because decapitation strategies have rarely worked in countering mass-mobilization terrorist or insurgent campaigns, but also because al-Qaida's ability to continue this struggle is based absolutely on its capacity to attract new recruits and replenish its resources.

"Without knowing our enemy, we cannot fulfill the most basic requirements of an effective counter-terrorist strategy: pre-empting and preventing terrorist operations and deterring their attacks," Hoffman added.

Officials said Friday that Abu Laith al-Libi — believed to have been killed when a missile fired by an unmanned U.S. aircraft hit his Pakistani hideout — was a top al-Qaida commander who led Osama bin Laden's terror network in Afghanistan.

He was in fifth position on a classified Central Intelligence Agency wanted list, with a $5 million bounty on his head.

But in using the "al-Qaida" label when talking about suspects arrested or armed fighters killed — indiscriminately and sometimes wrongly, whether in Afghanistan, Iraq or elsewhere — American or Western forces create and feed a confusion which ultimately makes victims of themselves, experts say.

"Using body counts as a criterion to measure effectiveness is a bit like Guantanamo: you produce a tally, you mix up al-Qaida members or just hired hands with people who have only the vaguest of connections, people who have none at all and finally even pure civilians," added French academic Jean-Pierre Filiu, author of "Les Frontieres du Jihad" (The Limits of Jihad).

"When you reach that point, air strikes and the elimination of 'wanted' individuals not only prove fruitless, but actually become counter-productive.

"These actions only intensify al-Qaida recruitment, instead of weakening the organisation.

"The problem is this innate tendency within all administrations or bodies to stack up figures, pull out statistics, use them to show how they are winning, how they are liquidating their enemies, etc," Filiu added.

The "body count" syndrome is actually a "trap" laid by al-Qaida into which the Americans have "fallen" blindly, added Lebanese-American researcher Fawaz Gerges, an international relations specialist at Sarah Lawrence College, New York.

"You cannot win this war on the battlefield, because there is none," said Gerges. "You're facing an unconventional war. The more you rely on military might, the more you lose the war of ideas against al-Qaida and the militants.

"In Iraq, we fell into their trap. We gave them more ideological ammunition. So many Muslims all over the world are now convinced, and this feeling is so entrenched, that the war in Iraq is not against al-Qaida, but against Islam."

Gerges detects a growing appreciation of this phenomenon "even at the heart of the American administration," expressing his belief that a "new understanding" exists which casts George W Bush's war against al-Qaida as "counter-productive."


The Times of India (Feb 4, 2008, Slain Al-Qaida commander openly met Pak officials in Peshawar):

ISLAMABAD: Top Al-Qaida commander Abu Laith al-Libi, killed last week in northwestern Pakistan, openly met Pakistani officials and a Libyan diplomat in Peshawar despite a USD 200,000 reward on his head, a media report said on Monday.

Libi's death in Pakistan was reported by Al Qaida-linked websites and it is believed he was among 12 militants who died in a missile strike carried out by an unmanned aerial vehicle on a house at Khushali Torikhel village in Pakistan's troubled North Waziristan tribal area on January 29.

The terrorist leader from Libya had lived in northwestern Pakistan for years and "felt secure enough to meet officials and visit hospitals" in Peshawar, the Washington Post quoted officials and residents of the city as saying.

As he organised suicide bombings and other attacks in Afghanistan, Libi "found a comfortable refuge in Pakistan's border region", the paper quoted sources as saying.

He "met openly with a Pakistani politician and a Libyan diplomat and called on foreign fighters recovering from their wounds".

The way in which Libi moved unchallenged around the heart of Peshawar, a city of 1.2 million people, underscored "how freely he and other Al-Qaida leaders have been able to operate in Pakistan", the report said.

On one occasion in 2006, Libi "strode into the central prison in Peshawar and another Libyan fighter sat behind bars in the custody of Pakistani authorities... the Al-Qaida leader, the Pakistani politician and the Libyan diplomat argued over whether the militant should be deported against his wishes to Libya or released to fight another day, said Javed Ibrahim Paracha, the PML-N leader who helped arrange the meeting.


(1) We are pursuing a policy that has rarely been successful in defeating insurgencies.

(2) Al-Qaida leaders have complete freedom of movement within Pakistan.

(3) Pakistan is not looking for bin Laden.

(4) Pakistan manages to lose terrorists held in custody.

(5) Jundallah - based in Pakistan - members claim to have been trained by US & British intelligence officers; there is "member movement" between Jundallah & Lashkar-e Jhangvi (LeJ), which "was involved, along with the Jaish e-Mohammad, in the abduction and murder of US journalist Daniel Pearl in January 2002".

(6) And the CIA and Musharraf collaborate for a little of the Great Carnac routine on the assassination of the former Pakistani leader who knew where all the dead bodies were buried (including Osama bin Laden's) from the CIA-ISI-jihadi adventures in Afghanistan and the Balkans.



Tuesday, January 8, 2008

Sibel Edmonds Explosive Revelations in the Times

The Times (UK, For sale: West’s deadly nuclear secrets, Jan 6, 2008):

...Sibel Edmonds, a 37-year-old former Turkish language translator for the FBI, listened into hundreds of sensitive intercepted conversations while based at the agency’s Washington field office.

She approached The Sunday Times last month after reading about an Al-Qaeda terrorist who had revealed his role in training some of the 9/11 hijackers while he was in Turkey.

Edmonds described how foreign intelligence agents had enlisted the support of US officials to acquire a network of moles in sensitive military and nuclear institutions. Among the hours of covert tape recordings, she says she heard evidence that one well-known senior official in the US State Department was being paid by Turkish agents in Washington who were selling the information on to black market buyers, including Pakistan.

The name of the official – who has held a series of top government posts – is known to The Sunday Times. He strongly denies the claims.

However, Edmonds said: “He was aiding foreign operatives against US interests by passing them highly classified information, not only from the State Department but also from the Pentagon, in exchange for money, position and political objectives.”

She claims that the FBI was also gathering evidence against senior Pentagon officials – including household names – who were aiding foreign agents.

“If you made public all the information that the FBI have on this case, you will see very high-level people going through criminal trials,” she said.

Her story shows just how much the West was infiltrated by foreign states seeking nuclear secrets. It illustrates how western government officials turned a blind eye to, or were even helping, countries such as Pakistan acquire bomb technology.

The wider nuclear network has been monitored for many years by a joint Anglo-American intelligence effort. But rather than shut it down, investigations by law enforcement bodies such as the FBI and Britain’s Revenue & Customs have been aborted to preserve diplomatic relations....

...She has given evidence to closed sessions of Congress and the 9/11 commission, but many of the key points of her testimony have remained secret. She has now decided to divulge some of that information after becoming disillusioned with the US authorities’ failure to act.

One of Edmonds’s main roles in the FBI was to translate thousands of hours of conversations by Turkish diplomatic and political targets that had been covertly recorded by the agency.

A backlog of tapes had built up, dating back to 1997, which were needed for an FBI investigation into links between the Turks and Pakistani, Israeli and US targets. Before she left the FBI in 2002 she heard evidence that pointed to money laundering, drug imports and attempts to acquire nuclear and conventional weapons technology.

“What I found was damning,” she said. “While the FBI was investigating, several arms of the government were shielding what was going on.”

The Turks and Israelis had planted “moles” in military and academic institutions which handled nuclear technology. Edmonds says there were several transactions of nuclear material every month, with the Pakistanis being among the eventual buyers. “The network appeared to be obtaining information from every nuclear agency in the United States,” she said.

They were helped, she says, by the high-ranking State Department official who provided some of their moles – mainly PhD students – with security clearance to work in sensitive nuclear research facilities. These included the Los Alamos nuclear laboratory in New Mexico, which is responsible for the security of the US nuclear deterrent.

In one conversation Edmonds heard the official arranging to pick up a $15,000 cash bribe. The package was to be dropped off at an agreed location by someone in the Turkish diplomatic community who was working for the network.

The Turks, she says, often acted as a conduit for the Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI), Pakistan’s spy agency, because they were less likely to attract suspicion. Venues such as the American Turkish Council in Washington were used to drop off the cash, which was picked up by the official.

Edmonds said: “I heard at least three transactions like this over a period of 2½ years. There are almost certainly more.”

The Pakistani operation was led by General Mahmoud Ahmad, then the ISI chief.

Intercepted communications showed Ahmad and his colleagues stationed in Washington were in constant contact with attachés in the Turkish embassy.

Intelligence analysts say that members of the ISI were close to Al-Qaeda before and after 9/11. Indeed, Ahmad was accused of sanctioning a $100,000 wire payment to Mohammed Atta, one of the 9/11 hijackers, immediately before the attacks.

The results of the espionage were almost certainly passed to Abdul Qadeer Khan, the Pakistani nuclear scientist.

Khan was close to Ahmad and the ISI. While running Pakistan’s nuclear programme, he became a millionaire by selling atomic secrets to Libya, Iran and North Korea. He also used a network of companies in America and Britain to obtain components for a nuclear programme.

Khan caused an alert among western intelligence agencies when his aides met Osama Bin Laden. “We were aware of contact between A Q Khan’s people and Al-Qaeda,” a former CIA officer said last week. “There was absolute panic when we initially discovered this, but it kind of panned out in the end.”

It is likely that the nuclear secrets stolen from the United States would have been sold to a number of rogue states by Khan.

Edmonds was later to see the scope of the Pakistani connections when it was revealed that one of her fellow translators at the FBI was the daughter of a Pakistani embassy official who worked for Ahmad. The translator was given top secret clearance despite protests from FBI investigators.

Edmonds says packages containing nuclear secrets were delivered by Turkish operatives, using their cover as members of the diplomatic and military community, to contacts at the Pakistani embassy in Washington.

Following 9/11, a number of the foreign operatives were taken in for questioning by the FBI on suspicion that they knew about or somehow aided the attacks.

Edmonds said the State Department official once again proved useful. “A primary target would call the official and point to names on the list and say, ‘We need to get them out of the US because we can’t afford for them to spill the beans’,” she said. “The official said that he would ‘take care of it’.”

The four suspects on the list were released from interrogation and extradited.

Edmonds also claims that a number of senior officials in the Pentagon had helped Israeli and Turkish agents.

“The people provided lists of potential moles from Pentagon-related institutions who had access to databases concerning this information,” she said.

“The handlers, who were part of the diplomatic community, would then try to recruit those people to become moles for the network. The lists contained all their ‘hooking points’, which could be financial or sexual pressure points, their exact job in the Pentagon and what stuff they had access to.”

One of the Pentagon figures under investigation was Lawrence Franklin, a former Pentagon analyst, who was jailed in 2006 for passing US defence information to lobbyists and sharing classified information with an Israeli diplomat.

“He was one of the top people providing information and packages during 2000 and 2001,” she said.

Once acquired, the nuclear secrets could have gone anywhere. The FBI monitored Turkish diplomats who were selling copies of the information to the highest bidder.

Edmonds said: “Certain greedy Turkish operators would make copies of the material and look around for buyers. They had agents who would find potential buyers.” In summer 2000, Edmonds says the FBI monitored one of the agents as he met two Saudi Arabian businessmen in Detroit to sell nuclear information that had been stolen from an air force base in Alabama. She overheard the agent saying: “We have a package and we’re going to sell it for $250,000.”....

...In researching this article, The Sunday Times has talked to two FBI officers (one serving, one former) and two former CIA sources who worked on nuclear proliferation. While none was aware of specific allegations against officials she names, they did provide overlapping corroboration of Edmonds’s story.

One of the CIA sources confirmed that the Turks had acquired nuclear secrets from the United States and shared the information with Pakistan and Israel. “We have no indication that Turkey has its own nuclear ambitions. But the Turks are traders. To my knowledge they became big players in the late 1990s,” the source said.





Dave Lindorff at Counterpunch (Jan 7., 2008, Sibel Edmonds, Turkey and the Bomb A Real 9/11 Cover-Up?) develops an interesting analysis in light of the mysterious Minot-Barksdale live nuke flight:

...If Edmonds' story is correct, and Al-Qaeda, with the aid of Turkish government agents and Pakistani intelligence, with the help of US government officials, has been attempting to obtain nuclear materials and nuclear information from the U.S., it casts an even darker shadow over the mysterious and still unexplained incident last August 30, when a B-52 Stratofortress, based at the Minot strategic air base in Minot, ND, against all rules and regulations of 40 years' standing, loaded and flew off with six unrecorded and unaccounted for nuclear-tipped cruise missiles.

That incident only came to public attention because three as yet unidentified Air Force whistleblowers contacted a reporter at the Military Times newspaper, which ran a series of stories about it, some of which were picked up by other US news organizations.

An Air Force investigation into that incident, ordered by Defense Secretary Robert Gates, claimed improbably that the whole thing had been an "accident," but many veterans of the US Air Force and Navy with experience in handling nuclear weapons say that such an explanation is impossible, and argue that there had to have been a chain or orders from above the level of the base commander for such a flight to have occurred.

Incredibly, almost five months after that bizarre incident (which included several as yet unexplained deaths of B-52 pilots and base personnel occurring in the weeks shortly before and after the flight), in which six 150-kiloton warheads went missing for 36 hours, there has been no Congressional investigation and no FBI investigation into what happened.

Yet in view of Edmonds' story to the London Times, alleging that there has been an ongoing, active effort for some years by both Al Qaeda and by agents of two US allies, Turkey and Pakistan, to get US nuclear weapons secrets and even weapons, and that there are treasonous moles at work within the American government and nuclear bureaucracy aiding and abetting those efforts, surely at a minimum, a major public inquiry is called for....



And now for some history:

Ewen MacAskill and Ian Traynor reported on The Guardian (September 18, 2003, Saudis consider nuclear bomb):

...Saudi Arabia, in response to the current upheaval in the Middle East, has embarked on a strategic review that includes acquiring nuclear weapons, the Guardian has learned....

...A strategy paper being considered at the highest levels in Riyadh sets out three options:

· To acquire a nuclear capability as a deterrent;

· To maintain or enter into an alliance with an existing nuclear power that would offer protection;

· To try to reach a regional agreement on having a nuclear-free Middle East.

Until now, the assumption in Washington was that Saudi Arabia was content to remain under the US nuclear umbrella. But the relationship between Saudi Arabia and the US has steadily worsened since the September 11 attacks on New York and Washington: 15 of the 19 attackers were Saudi....

...In 1988, Saudi bought from China intermediate-range missiles capable of reaching any part of the Middle East with a nuclear warhead.

Four years ago, Saudi Arabia sent a defence team to Pakistan to tour its secret nuclear facilities and to be briefed by Abdul Qader Khan, the father of Pakistan's nuclear bomb....


Arnaud de Borchgrave, editor at large for UPI, reported on the Washington Times (October 22, 2003, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia in secret nuke pact, repost on GlobalSecurity):


Pakistan and Saudi Arabia have concluded a secret agreement on "nuclear cooperation" that will provide the Saudis with nuclear-weapons technology in exchange for cheap oil, according to a ranking Pakistani insider.

The disclosure came at the end of a 26-hour state visit to Islamabad last weekend by Crown Prince Abdullah bin Abdulaziz, Saudi Arabia's de facto ruler, who flew across the Arabian Sea with an entourage of 200, including Foreign Minister Prince Saud Al Faisal and several Cabinet ministers....

..."It will be vehemently denied by both countries," said the Pakistani source, whose information has proven reliable for more than a decade, "but future events will confirm that Pakistan has agreed to provide [Saudi Arabia] with the wherewithal for a nuclear deterrent." ....

...But the CIA believes Pakistan already has shared its nuclear know-how, working with North Korea in exchange for missile technology.

A Pakistani C-130 was spotted by satellite loading North Korean missiles at Pyongyang airport last year. Pakistan, which is estimated to have between 35 and 60 nuclear weapons, said this was a straight purchase for cash and strongly denied a nuclear quid pro quo.

"Both Pakistan and Saudi Arabia," the Pakistani source said, "see a world that is moving from nonproliferation to proliferation of nuclear weapons."


The APS Diplomatic News Service (Nov 10, 2003, Saudi-Pakistani Nuclear Linkage Marks The Opening Of A Sunni Muslim Security Umbrella) had this information:

...in 1999, a Saudi defence delegation led by Defence Minister Prince Sultan visited Pakistan to tour its secret nuclear facilities at Kahuta and to be briefed by Dr. Abdul Qader Khan, the father of Pakistan's nuclear bomb. That visit raised alarms in the West because a tour of the super-secret Kahuta facility was denied even to elected Pakistani prime ministers (like Benazir Bhutto) by the country's military establishment. A paper by the South Asia Analysis Group dated Oct. 1 claimed there were "reports emerging but not confirmed that Pakistan has stored some nuclear weapons in storage in Saudi Arabia, but to remain under Pakistani control".

On Oct. 20, Arnaud de Borchgrave, editor-in-chief of United Press International (UPI) and a veteran American journalist with excellent connections in Pakistan, reported that a "ranking" and "unimpeachable Pakistani source" had informed him that "Pakistan and Saudi Arabia have concluded a secret agreement on nuclear cooperation" - during the visit by Crown Prince Abdullah to Islamabad at the head of a 200-member delegation including Foreign Minister Prince Saud. De Borchgrave added that the source claimed: "It will be vehemently denied by both countries... but future events will confirm that Pakistan has agreed to provide KSA (Kingdom of Saudi Arabia) with the wherewithal for a nuclear deterrent".

Subsequent to the de Borchgrave article, another report by Global Information Systems/Defence and Foreign Affairs Weekly, written by Yossef Bodansky and Gregrory R. Copley, said their "highly reliable" sources in Islamabad and Riyadh reported on Oct. 21 that Islamabad and Riyadh had "reached a secret but definitive agreement to station nuclear weapons on Saudi soil, fitted to a new generation of Chinese-supplied long-range (4,000 to 5,000 km) ballistic missiles which would be under Pakistani command, but clearly with some form of joint Saudi-Pakistani command and control".

Like de Borchgrave, Bodansky and Copley claimed that the deal was struck during Abdullah's visit to Pakistan, adding that they had also discussed the issue at an unreported one-to-one meeting on the margins of the Organisation of Islamic Conference (OIC) meeting in Kuala Lumpur on Oct. 15. The GIS/Defence and Foreign Affairs weekly pointed out that basing nuclear weapons in Saudi Arabia would give Islamabad a second-strike capability to deter an Indian nuclear or conventional attack. For Saudi Arabia it eases concerns about Israel. During the Saudi delegation's visit, Foreign Minister Prince Saud Al Faisal said in Islamabad on Oct. 19 that Indian-Israel military cooperation was a "worrying element" which could unleash instability and arms race in the region.


The Center for Defense Information had this interesting revelation on June 30, 2005 (Saudi Nuclear Intentions and the IAEA Small Quantities Protocol):

Saudi Arabia’s recent signing of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Small Quantities Protocol on June 16, 2005, raises larger issues of possible nuclear ambitions on the Arabian Peninsula....

...The controversy centers on Saudi Arabia’s request to the IAEA to sign the Small Quantities protocol in May, after an internal IAEA document came to light calling for a change in the status of the Protocol over concerns it may pose a proliferation risk. The Protocol allows states considered to be of low risk to opt out of more intensive inspection regimes in return for a declaration of their nuclear activities. In addition, the Protocol allows for the possession of up to 10 tons of natural uranium or 20 tons of depleted uranium, and 2.2 pounds of plutonium without reporting. While it does not appear that Saudi Arabia aspires to develop a domestic weapons grade uranium or plutonium-processing ability, 10 tons of natural uranium is still enough by most standards to produce between one and four nuclear devices (depending on their design)....

...There is a slew of evidence that Saudi Arabia sought to acquire nuclear capabilities as early as 1975 when a nuclear research center at Al-Suleiyel was created. Further evidence points to a transfer of up to $5 billion to Iraq from 1985 until just prior to the first Gulf War in a deal to further the Iraqi nuclear program in exchange for weapons, should the program prove successful. There was apparently also an offer on the table to pay for reconstruction of the Osirak reactor destroyed by Israel, whose covert nuclear capabilities make it a mutual concern of Iraq and Saudi Arabia. Lastly, several high-level exchanges between Saudi and Pakistani officials and a general warming of relations between these two countries points to Saudi Arabia not only having the intent, motivation, and impetus to procure nuclear weapons, but now also the means.

Interestingly enough, any nuclear threat Saudi Arabia may face from Iran may actually have been proliferated by those whose nuclear program was also funded by the Saudis and whose help the Saudis are now seeking: Pakistan. After the mid-1994 defection to the United States of a former Saudi ambassador to the United Nations, Muhammad Khilewi, thousands of documents were uncovered, some of which hinted at an agreement by which Saudi Arabia partially funded Pakistan’s bomb project in exchange for retaliation with these nuclear weapons in the event of nuclear aggression against the Saudis. In 1999, the reciprocity of this nuclear alliance became even more apparent as Saudi Second Deputy Prime Minister Prince Sultan bin Abdul Aziz visited Pakistan’s Kahuta uranium enrichment plant with Pakistan’s Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and both were personally briefed by Dr A.Q. Khan. Then, in 2002, a son of Crown Prince Abdullah attended the firing of the Ghauri, Pakistan’s new nuclear-capable medium-range missile. Further attesting to the cordial nature of the alliance, Nawaz Sahrif, the prime minister of Pakistan deposed by Pervez Musharraf’s 1999 coup, was given amnesty in Saudi Arabia through a deal worked out between Islamabad and Riyadh.

Other evidence for having nuclear intentions stems from Saudi Arabia’s 1988 purchase of between 50 and 60 Chinese CSS-2 missiles. While these missiles are now largely considered obsolete, it is the purchase of a nuclear capable missile with a 3,500 km range and 2,500 kg capacity that is damaging to Saudi claims of innocence. Apparently of concern is the gross inaccuracy of the Chinese missile, rendering it completely ineffective for use with traditional warhead payloads. This points to a possible conclusion that one intended use could be with nuclear warheads, whose destructive radius negates the inherent inaccuracy of the missile. In addition, there has been recent speculation of prospective purchases of more modern Chinese missile systems (such as the CSS-5 and CSS-6) by Saudi Arabia.



G. Parthasarathy (a former High Commissioner to Pakistan) reported in The Hindu Business Line on Oct 25, 2002 (Pervez the proliferator):


...The US has a track record of feigning amnesia in dealing with nuclear or missile proliferation by it friends such as Pakistan and China. When the Reagan administration needed Pakistan's assistance to force the Soviet Union out of Afghanistan, President Zia-ul-Haq sent his highly capable Chief of Staff, Gen K.M. Arif, to tell Washington that Pakistan's support would be forthcoming only if no queries were raised about its nuclear weapons programme. The Reagan administration duly obliged. For nearly a decade Washington turned a Nelson's eye to Pakistan's moves to acquire nuclear weapons capability and build a nuclear arsenal with Chinese assistance.

Similarly, when China supplied M 11, and medium-range M 9 missiles to Pakistan, the Clinton administration claimed that as it had not been able to conclusively determine such supplies were taking place, it would not implement American laws requiring sanctions against both China and Pakistan. Gen Powell will, no doubt, find equally convoluted reasons for avoiding sanctions required to be imposed on Pakistan by the US law....

...There is now ample evidence to establish that not only did China provide nuclear weapon designs to Pakistan in the 1980s, but it also augmented and sustained Pakistan's nuclear-enrichment facilities by the supply of critical components such as ring magnets more recently. Less than two years after Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi's visit to China, in December 1988, China commenced supply of nuclear-capable M 11 missiles to Pakistan.

It has assisted Pakistan not only by supplying missile components, but also by establishing a missile production unit described as the National Development Complex at Fatehjang in Punjab province. This complex produces the M 9 missiles with a range of around 750 km (christened "Shaheen I" by the Pakistanis) and the intermediate range M 18 missiles (Shaheen II). China has, thus, given Pakistan the delivery systems for missiles that can target most population centres in India. These are realities that cannot be ignored by India in dealing with China.

Pakistan's missile collaboration with North Korea started in the 1990s, when Ms Benazir Bhutto made a secret visit to Pyongyang. Pakistan's nuclear scientist, Dr A.Q. Khan, also visited Pyongyang on a number of occasions. It is now evident that the two sides agreed that in return for North Korea's supply of its nuclear-capable 1200-km range "Nodong" missile, Pakistan would provide the equipment and know-how for Pyongyang to develop gas centrifuge facilities to produce weapons grade enriched uranium. It is inconceivable that such an agreement could have been arrived at between two close allies of China without Beijing's knowledge and approval.

This deal enabled North Korea to go ahead with a nuclear weapons programme, even while pretending to adhere to conditions set by the US and Japan not to develop nuclear weapons capabilities, and subject its plutonium producing facilities to international inspections. There are reports indicating that the nuclear-missile trade between Islamabad and Pyongyang is routed across the Karakoram Highway through China.

In these circumstances, queries do arise about whether there are any other parts of the world to which the China-Pakistan missile/nuclear collaboration extends.

Even when Beijing and Riyadh did not have diplomatic relations, China supplied Saudi Arabia with intermediate range (2000 km) CSS 2 ballistic missiles in the mid-1980s. Unlike in the 1980s, China today needs oil supplies from West Asia. Saudi Arabia is the logical source. At the same time, the otherwise tight-fisted Saudis, who prefer to spend their surplus money in spreading Wahabi extremism rather than financing economic development, have been more than generous in their economic assistance to Pakistan. It was Saudi Arabia that bailed out Pakistan, when its economy was on the verge of collapse following its May 1998 nuclear weapons tests, with supplies of oil at highly concessional credit terms....




AFX (repost on Forbes, March 28, 2006, Saudia Arabia working on secret nuclear program with Pakistan help - report):


Saudi Arabia is working secretly on a nuclear program, with help from Pakistani experts, the German magazine Cicero reported in its latest edition, citing Western security sources.

It says that during the Haj pilgrimages to Mecca in 2003 through 2005, Pakistani scientists posed as pilgrims to come to Saudi Arabia.

Between October 2004 and January 2005, some of them slipped off from pilgrimages, sometimes for up to three weeks, the report quoted German security expert Udo Ulfkotte as saying.

According to Western security services, the magazine added, Saudi scientists have been working since the mid-1990s in Pakistan, a nuclear power since 1998.

Cicero, which will appear on newstands tomorrow, also quoted a US military analyst, John Pike, as saying that Saudi bar codes can be found on half of Pakistan's nuclear weapons 'because it is Saudi Arabia which ultimately co-financed the Pakistani atomic nuclear program.'

The magazine also said satellite images indicate that Saudi Arabia has set up a program in Al-Sulaiyil, south of Riyadh, a secret underground city and dozens of underground silos for missiles.

According to some Western security services, long-range Ghauri-type missiles of Pakistani-origin are housed inside the silos.



See Chris Deliso's blog entry on AntiWar.com for some Dennis Hastert & Bill Clinton antics (Hastert, Helicopters, Textron, Turkey, Cash…, August 14, 2005). Lynn Grant's Hastert’s Turkish Allies Tied to Bin Laden (August 15, 2005, repost on Information Clearinghouse) is a must read.

Also note that much of the mujihadeen insurgency against the Soviets was financed by the CIA, and the Saudis - through "charity" donations (see the BBC, The Saudi Connection, How Jihad Made Its Way to Chechnya, How Saudi wealth fueled holy war, and Peter Dale Scott's Al Qaeda, U.S. Oil Companies, and Central Asia). Note that beginning in the late 1990s/early 2000s, Turkey began to feel the influx of Saudi charity - between $6 billion and $12 billon, and that the Saudis have been directly funding the Sunni insurgents in Iraq.



Monday, January 7, 2008

Pakistan not looking for bin Laden

Agence France-Presse reports today:

Pakistan is not specifically looking for Al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden, as there is no proof he is in Pakistan, President Pervez Musharraf said Sunday.

"We are not particularly looking for him, but we are operating against terrorists and Al Qaeda and militant Taliban. And in the process, obviously, combined, maybe we are looking for him also," the Pakistani leader told CBS television in an interview aired late Sunday.

Asked what Pakistan was doing to find the mastermind of the September 11, 2001 attacks, Musharraf said it was fighting extremism and terrorism.

"We are fighting first of all Al-Qaeda. Let's take Al-Qaeda. We have arrested or eliminated about 700 Al-Qaeda leaders ... which other country has done this?"

"Well, which other country has Bin Laden?" his CBS interviewer replied, inciting a sharp retort from the Pakistani leader.

"No, I challenge -- I don't accept that at all. There is no proof whatsoever that he is here in Pakistan."

Mahmoud Ali Durrani, Pakistan's envoy to the United States, sought to clarify Musharraf's remark, in an exchange with CNN.....

...Durrani noted that US and other foreign intelligence agencies believe bin Laden to be sheltering in the tribal area along the border between Pakistan and Afghanistan.

But "that's just speculation," the envoy said.

"Believe me. If they knew or we knew we would have taken him out," he
said....

...The New York Times reported that under a proposal being discussed in Washington, CIA operatives based in Afghanistan would be able to call on direct military support for counter-terrorism operations in neighboring Pakistan.




On Sunday, Agence France-Presse reported:

The Pakistani military reacted angrily Sunday to reports that US President George W. Bush is considering covert military operations in the country's volatile tribal areas bordering Afghanistan.

"It is not up to the US administration, it is Pakistan's government who is responsible for this country," chief military spokesman Major General Waheed Arshad told AFP.

"There are no overt or covert US operations inside Pakistan. Such reports are baseless and we reject them."....

Friday, January 4, 2008

Will Mushie finally get his F-16s?

Reuters on News.com.au (Jan 1, 2008, Lockheed to supply 18 F-16s to Pakistan) reports:

LOCKHEED Martin Corp (LMT.N) was awarded a $US498.2 million ($569.53 million) contract to supply F-16 aircraft to Pakistan...

...Lockheed will sell 12 F-16C plus 6 F-16D planes to Pakistan under the contract...

...Pakistan has received about $US10 billion ($11.43 billion) in US funding since 2001 ...

...The US has agreed to sell Pakistan up to 36 new F-16 jets together with refurbished F-16s....


This is part of the deal made in 2003, and finalized in 2005, as reported by Kyodo News (June 24, 2003, Pakistan expects to get 28 F-16s from U.S., now on FindArticles):


...It said that in exchange for the package, Pakistan would provide greater operation access to U.S. troops in seeking out al-Qaida and Taliban activists hiding in Pakistan, particularly in tribal areas adjoining Pakistan.

During the war against then Soviet Union troops in the 1980s, Pakistan had negotiated purchase of 28 F-16 aircraft from the U.S., but their supply was withheld when the U.S. imposed an embargo on all economic and military assistance to Pakistan in 1990 because of its nuclear program.

The U.S. wrote off $1 billion in loans to Pakistan and rescheduled the remaining $2 billion for repayment over a period of 35 years after the 2001 terrorist attack on the U.S. The think tank suggested that remaining $2 billion may get written off now.


The Islamic Republic News Agency (Iran) (Pakistan receives two F-16s fighter planes: official posted here) reported the arrival of two of the jets' order in December 2005, after Musharraf decided to postpone additional purchases due to earthquake relief needs. The Taipei Times reported (Nov 6, 2005, Pakistan postpones buying F-16s) "An F-16 can cost up to about US$40 million, depending on the model and the configuration." Pakistan has already purchased the Swedish version of AWACS. The Associated Press on the Sydney Morning Herald (March 26, 2005, Bush rewards Pakistan with fleet of F-16s) notes that Pakistan paid in advance for their 1980s F16s, that order never being completed.

Thursday, January 3, 2008

Coincidence? One week after Bhutto's murder, 1986 Karachi hijackers freed

Agence France-Presse reports on News.com.au (Jan 4, 2008):

PAKISTANI authorities released four Palestinians who were involved in the bloody hijacking of an American plane in 1986.

The group commandeered a Pan Am jet at Karachi airport and the 16-hour drama ended when Pakistan troops stormed the plane.

The shootout left 22 people dead and more than 100 wounded. The hijackers were arrested and convicted by a Pakistani court.

"They had completed their sentences about four years ago and since then they had been living as internees," Adiala Jail superintendent Mohsin Rafiq said.

Negotiations were underway for their repatriation with the Palestinian authorities, he said.

They were supposed to leave for their home country, according to Mr Rafiq.




And now, some history:

From the BBC:

1986: Karachi hijack ends in bloodshed

The 16-hour siege on a Pan Am jet in Pakistan has come to a bloody end, with at least 17 people dead.

Four gunmen, who boarded the Bombay to New York flight at Karachi Airport disguised as security guards, opened fire on the 390 hostages at 2130 local time (1630 GMT).

Some passengers were able to escape the carnage down one of the plane's emergency chutes, but it is thought to have been at least 10 minutes before Pakistani commandos reached the jet.

The still unknown hijackers, two of whom are believed to be dead, had earlier demanded a new flight crew to take them to Cyprus to secure the release of "friends".

The original crew escaped from the cockpit shortly after the gunmen boarded at 0500 (0000 GMT).

Most of the passengers on Pan Am 073 are Indian, but Americans, Italians, West Germans and Britons are also on the plane.

They were moved to the centre of the aircraft when the power began to fail and the jet was plunged into darkness.

Businessman Mohammed Amin said he heard one hijacker tell another: "The moment of the Last Jihad has arrived. If we are all killed we will all be martyrs."

They then counted "one, two, three" before they began shooting, he added.

US passenger David Jodice told reporters: "They were shouting at us in pitch darkness. We were totally panicked when they threw a hand grenade in among the passengers.

"I have seen a lot of blood - I cannot guess how many people were killed or wounded," he said.

The hijackers had already killed American passenger Rajesh Kumar, 29, and dumped his body out of the door when their demand for a new pilot was not met.

Two previously unknown groups - the Libyan Revolutionary Cells and the Jundallah (Soldiers of God) - have claimed the men were acting on their behalf. Experts say it is unlikely Libyan leader Colonel Muammar Gaddafi, fearful of more American raids on his country, will want to be openly associated with the hijacking.

IN CONTEXT
Twenty-two people died in the attack and over 150 were injured.

Contrary to initial reports, all the hijackers survived. They later admitted to being members of the Palestinian Abu Nidal Organisation.

Five men were convicted in Pakistan for their part in the attack in 1988. They were all sentenced to death, but this was later commuted to life imprisonment.

The Pakistani authorities released the leader of the hijackers, Zaid Hassan Abd Al-Latif Masud Al Safarini in September 2001, but he was quickly recaptured by the US. He was tried in an American court and in 2004 was sentenced to a 160-year prison term. The other four men remain in jail in Pakistan.


The Associated Press on the New York Times (July 7, 1988):

... Pakistani commandos stormed the plane after it sat on the tarmac for 17
hours. Two Americans were among the dead.
Throughout the trial the
defendants blamed the Pakistani commandos for the killings.
Judge Syed
Zafar Babar discounted that argument but found the defendants guilty of only 11
deaths, saying there was insufficient evidence to convict them of more....

...Mohammed Hafiz al-Turk, a Palestinian from Libya who is believed to have
planned the hijacking, was convicted of conspiracy. He was the only one of the
five not to board the Boeing 747. He was arrested in Islamabad, Pakistan's
capital, less than a week after the hijacking.

The other four defendants - Mohammed Ahmed al-Munawar, Khalil Hussain
Rahayyal and Sayed Abdul Rahim, all from Lebanon, and Abdul Latif Sairfani, of
Syria - were convicted of hijacking and murder.

They were sentenced to death for their roles in the hijacking and to 10
consecutive life sentences for the deaths of 10 people. Three of the four men received an additional life sentence in the killing of an 11th person
....



Abu Nidal's organization ... blast from the past. Tom Gross Media website has a good, brief history on Nidal, and some interesting tidbits ... like "plans for an American attack on Iraq were found in his Baghdad apartment" when he 'committed suicide' (August 17, 2002).

As for "Libyan Revolutionary Cells", try googling on that exact (with quotes) phrase, you get just 1 return - its a real Googlewhack! Unhide the "ommitted results", and you find the same content duplicated across two other sites about the "Libyan Revolutionary Cells" ... it would appear these are a product of some intel service's imagination.

On March 28, 2004, The Sunday Times reported:

....Disclosing this for the first time last week, western and Pakistani intelligence sources said Gadaffi had hired a group of Palestinian terrorists to hijack a Pan Am jumbo jet carrying 379 passengers and crew, including 89 Americans, and explode it over Tel Aviv.

Had the jumbo jet blown up and crashed into the city, as the Libyan leader intended, the carnage would have been colossal — much greater than that caused by the destruction of Pan Am flight 103 over Lockerbie in Scotland, in which 281 people died.

But Gadaffi’s bomb plot failed. Pakistani troops stormed the plane while it was on the ground at Karachi airport. Twenty-two people, including two Americans, were killed and 100 wounded. All the terrorists were captured.

They have now completed their prison sentences in Pakistan. The first one to be freed has been rearrested by the American authorities, however, and convicted a second time for the hijacking.

Just before Christmas, Zayd Hassan Safarini was given three consecutive life sentences by a Washington court for murder, air piracy and hostage-taking after he struck an agreement with the court to escape a death sentence. When he was released he went to Amman, Jordan, but was later arrested by the FBI while changing planes at Bangkok airport. He had already spent more than 15 years in jail.

As a result the four others, including the Libyan mastermind, are refusing to leave prison in Pakistan. They fear that the moment they are free they too will be seized by a vengeful America and tried a second time.

Gadaffi himself has nothing to fear. Unlike Lockerbie, the Karachi hijacking has never been publicly blamed on him, although Pakistani and western intelligence agencies were soon aware that he was responsible and that the hijackers had been on a suicide mission.

In a clever ruse, Pakistani intelligence agents tricked the arrested hijackers into confessing that they were working for the Libyan leader. The incriminating details have remained secret until now, and the full details of the plot did not even come out at the trial.

One reason Libya was never publicly linked to the incident was Pakistan’s reluctance to tarnish the head of a Muslim state. There is widespread Pakistani sympathy for the Palestinian cause, which the hijackers said they were seeking to promote.

Indeed President Zia ul-Haq, the Pakistani leader at the time, described the hijackers as “very motivated and highly volatile youngsters”.

...America is also rehabilitating the Libyan leader after he agreed to pay hundreds of millions of dollars in compensation.
But it has not given up on punishing the hijackers. Its arrest warrants still stand.

Revenge drove Gadaffi to order the Karachi hijacking. Five months earlier, in April 1986, President Ronald Reagan had sent jets to bomb Tripoli. Gadaffi himself was targeted. Scores died, including his one-year-old adopted daughter.

The American raid was punishment for the Libyan bombing of a Berlin discotheque in which two American servicemen died.

It put Gadaffi into a rage and he ordered the Libyan external intelligence service under his brother-in-law Abdullah Senoussi to retaliate.

According to intelligence sources, a plan was concocted with Gadaffi’s approval to hijack Pan Am flight 73 from Bombay to Frankfurt and New York and blast it out of the sky over Israel in reprisal.

Senoussi hired the services of Abu Nidal, the notorious Palestinian hitman. Nidal died in Baghdad in 2002, a broken reed. But in the 1980s, when he lived in Libya, his terrorist group was the most feared in the world. Financed by Libya he hired out gunmen to Arab governments to mount attacks on western and Israeli targets.

The terrorists flew to Pakistan and were provided with explosives and guns that had been smuggled in by diplomatic bag. They dressed up as Karachi airport security officers and seized the airliner when it landed on the first leg of its journey from Bombay. Beneath the uniforms, explosives were strapped to their bodies.

The operation went wrong when the American pilot escaped from an emergency exit. The plane was grounded. The hijackers executed an American passenger and dumped his body on the tarmac. After 18 hours trapped inside, the gunmen panicked when the lights failed. They opened fire and hurled grenades at the passengers as Pakistani troops stormed the plane.

All the terrorists were captured on the spot bar one — the Libyan organiser, Salman Ali al-Turki. He went on the run. But when he contacted the Libyan embassy a few days later asking them to contact Senoussi and arrange his escape from Pakistan, he was arrested.

The terrorists refused to break under interrogation so the Pakistani intelligence service concocted a brazen piece of deception. It tricked them into believing Gadaffi was dead by printing a dummy copy of a newspaper with a front page banner headline announcing his sudden demise in a plane crash.

When the paper was delivered to their cells, the terrorists broke down and confessed that the Libyan leader had sponsored their mission. It was no longer necessary to keep his role secret, they said, now that their hero was dead.

At the time of the hijacking, Gadaffi was attending a non-aligned summit in Harare, where he adopted a belligerent anti-American tone. He also planted a clue that gave him away, by boasting that an attack on America was imminent.

This statement, carried by a Libyan news agency, alerted the Pakistanis to Gadaffi’s possible involvement. But without the newspaper ruse they would never have known for sure. The Karachi hijacking was the first attempt by terrorists to crash an airliner into a city. It failed, but it set a deadly trend....



They're sentenced to hang, then commuted to life sentences .... and they're released a mere 15-16 years later. Well, it'll be interesting to see if those American warrants will get exercised.

The other affiliation - Jundallah - is described as a Sunni group in Iran, and is opposed to the Iranian government. Massoud Ansari on The Telegraph ('We will cut them until Iran asks for mercy', Jan 17, 2006) describes them as a fanatical Sunni group operating in southeastern Iran, and Tehran accuses the US of supporting them.

Margarita Snegireva on Pravda (Four members of terrorist Jundallah group killed by Iranian police, Dec 20, 2007) reported that four of their leaders had been killed in clashes with Iranian police; 12 had been killed in a shootout with security forces earlier in December; and one had been hanged in February for the killing of Revolutionary Guards in the bombing that month (media coverage of the bombings are on Chris Elliot's blogpost A War On Terrorism or a War Of Terrorism? on Democrats.com). In 2005, Jundallah kidnapped an Iranian intelligence officer (Shehab Mansuri) and murdered him. At WindsOfChange (May 22, 2005), Dan Darling reviews media reports about Jundallah, which claim that the al Qaeda infrastructure has established itself in the Gaza Strip and calls itself Jundallah.


From Greg Elich's Washington's Covert War inside Iran (Global Research Center, March 23, 2007, posted here and here on ZNet):

...According to a former CIA official, funding for armed separatist groups operating in Iran is paid from the CIA's classified budget. The aim, claims Fred Burton, an ex-State Department counter-terrorism agent, is "to supply and train" these groups "to destabilize the Iranian regime." (1)

The largest and most well known of the anti-government organizations is Mujahedin-e Khalq (MEK), operating out of Iraq.... Camp Ashraf ... located well outside of Baghdad, where many of the MEK fighters are stationed. But the camp
operates under the protection of the U.S. military, and American soldiers chauffeur MEK leaders. The Iraqi government is unlikely to get its way, as the MEK claims to be the primary U.S. source for intelligence on Iran. (3)....

...Reliance on the MEK began under Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld with the direction of Vice President Dick Cheney, and soon MEK soldiers were being used in special operations missions in Iran. "They are doing whatever they want, no oversight at all," said one intelligence official of the MEK's American handlers. (4)....

...The Party for a Free Life in Kurdistan (PJAK), is another organization that conducts cross-border raids into Iran. Israel provides the group with "equipment and training," claims a consultant to the U.S. Defense Department, while the U.S. gave it "a list of targets inside Iran of interest to the U.S."....

...Jundallah (God's Brigade) is an extremist Sunni organization operating in Sistan-Balochistan province that has been launching armed attacks, planting explosives, setting off car bombs, and kidnapping. Based in Pakistan, it is unclear if this group is connected with the Pakistani organization of the same name, which has ties with Al-Qaeda. (7) Jundallah denies that it has any links to either Al-Qaeda or to the U.S. But Iranian officials claim that a recently arrested Jundallah guerrilla has confessed that he was trained by U.S. and British intelligence officers. There is no way to verify that such a confession has actually taken place, nor its reliability as it may have come as a result of coercion, but the claim would not be inconsistent with U.S. policy elsewhere in Iran. (8)....

...CIA support for the anti-Soviet and anti-socialist Mujahedin in Afghanistan spawned a worldwide movement of Islamic extremism. Western support for ethnic secessionists shattered Yugoslavia and the invasion of Iraq fired the flames of ethnic discord and made a shared life impossible. It remains to be seen if the Bush Administration can succeed in achieving its goal of effecting regime change in Iran....

The Australian Government notes that there is member movement between Jundallah and Lashkar-e Jhangvi (LeJ) which "has assassinated Iranian nationals in Pakistan and was involved, along with the Jaish e-Mohammad, in the abduction and murder of US journalist Daniel Pearl in January 2002".


Bhutto's Assassination.... Before Election Rigging Rpt to be Released

Reuters on the New Zealand Herald (Bhutto 'was about to spill the beans', Jan 3, 2008) has this interesting insight:


KARACHI - Benazir Bhutto was poised to offer proof that Pakistan's election commission and shadowy spy agency were seeking to rig an upcoming general election the night she was assassinated, a top aide said.

Senator Latif Khosa, who authored a 160-page dossier with Bhutto documenting rigging tactics, said they ranged from intimidation to fake ballots, and were in some cases unwittingly funded by US aid.

Bhutto had been due to give the report to two visiting US legislators over dinner on the day she was killed in a suicide bombing.

"The state agencies are manipulating the whole process," said Khosa, head of Bhutto's Pakistan People's Party election monitoring unit.

"There is rigging by the ISI (Inter-Services Intelligence), the election commission and the previous government ... They were on the rampage."....

...Khosa said the report, entitled "Yet another stain on the face of democracy", detailed how the spy agency was planning to issue 25,000 pre-stamped ballots for each of 108 candidates for national assembly seats in Punjab from the party that backs President Musharraf.

He said the ISI also had a "mega computer" which could hack into any computer and was connected to the Election Commission's system.

An initial draft list of voters published in June put the electorate at 52 million people, more than 20 million short, triggering a backlash from Musharraf's political opponents.

The Supreme Court ordered the commission to revise the list, and in October it raised the total to 80 million.

"Benazir was supposed to hold a press conference. It was going to be distributed to everyone, but unfortunately that did not arise because she was assassinated," Khosa said.


Monday, December 31, 2007

Bhutto's Assassination

Britain’s Channel 4 News has obtained video footage of the assassination, and 3 gunshots are clearly heard, and her hair and scarf are disturbed, and then the suicide bomb goes off.

Jane Perlez, on the New York Times (repost on the Seattle Post-Intelligencer), notes:

...Athar Minallah, a board member of the hospital where Bhutto was treated, released her medical report along with an open letter showing that her doctors wanted to distance themselves from the government theory that Bhutto had died by hitting her head on a lever of her car's sunroof during the attack....

...Pakistani and Western security experts said the government's insistence that Bhutto, a former prime minister, was not killed by a bullet was designed to deflect attention from the lack of government security around her. On Sunday, photographs in Pakistani newspapers showed a man apparently pointing a gun at her from just yards away....

...Minallah distributed the medical report with his open letter to the Pakistani news media and The New York Times. He said the doctor who wrote the report, Mohammad Mussadiq Khan, the principal professor of surgery at the Rawalpindi General Hospital, told him on the night of Bhutto's death that she had died of a bullet wound....

Syed Saleem Shahzad on the Asia Times reports on "Al Qaeda's" claim of responsibility:

"We terminated the most precious American asset which vowed to defeat mujahideen.” These were the words of al-Qaeda’s top commander for Afghanistan operations and spokesperson Mustafa Abu al-Yazid, immediately after the attack that claimed the life of Pakistani politician Benazir Bhutto on Thursday (December 27)....

...“This is our first major victory against those [eg, Bhutto and President Pervez Musharraf] who have been siding with infidels [the West] in a fight against al-Qaeda and declared a war against mujahideen,” Mustafa told Asia Times Online by telephone....

...On December 6, a Pakistani intelligence agency tracked a cell phone conversation between a militant leader and a local cleric, in which a certain Maulana Asadullah Khalidi was named. The same day, Khalidi was arrested during a raid in Karachi. The arrest, in turn, led to the arrest of a very high-profile non-Pakistani militant leader, which, it is said, revealed an operation aimed at wiping out “precious American assets” in Pakistan, including Musharraf and Bhutto....

...Bhutto was the only Pakistani leader who regularly spoke against al-Qaeda....

The Associated Press and the Telegraph both have transcripts up of an al-Qaeda intercept, between senior al-Qa'eda leader Baitullah Mehsud and Maulvi Sahib, intercepted AFTER the assassination.

RIA Novosti political commentator Pyotr Goncharov offers this analysis:

... Bhutto's return to Pakistan last October was a triumph and a scandal at the same time. On the day of her return when the escort was moving along one of the central roads of her native Karachi to the greetings of numerous supporters, two explosions killed more than 140 people. Bhutto was not harmed, but Pakistani security-related services were said to be involved in the terrorist attack. President Pervez Musharraf was also suspected. These suspicions have not been cleared to this day.

But it was at least absurd to suspect Musharraf of involvement in Bhutto's assassination. He had a much bigger stake in Bhutto's heading the cabinet after the parliamentary elections. He could not fail to understand that her party was bound to win the elections after an eight-year exile, and possibly, by a landslide. For this reason, Musharraf desperately needed an alliance with the PPP. Pakistan's main sponsors - the United States and Britain, who regard Bhutto and the PPP as democracy incarnate, would have never forgiven Musharraf any other coalition.


Finally, by giving up his general's uniform, Musharraf managed to consolidate the power of a civil president, as well as his personal power; he actually precluded any encroachments on it on behalf of his military and civilian opponents. He set up a national command department to ensure the security and reliability of nuclear facilities. One can imagine what powers the department has received with the presence of nuclear weapons in the country and the threat of the extremist forces coming to power.

The president headed the new department, while the prime minister was appointed his deputy. In this context, Musharraf also made Bhutto his supporter. This position of his was shared by his supporters.

Literally, a day before Bhutto's assassination, Pakistani Ambassador to Russia Kamal Kazi told me that Bhutto was going to be the next prime minister and that other options were unlikely. We talked about the role of women in modern Pakistan, and the ambassador said that his guests would be able to see the Pakistani Prime Minister without a veil. It was clear whom he meant....

Professor M.D. Nalapat, vice-chair of the Manipal Advanced Research Group, UNESCO Peace Chair, and professor of geopolitics at Manipal University, provides this analysis on UPI Asia Online:

...The skepticism over her longevity was because of the threat she represented to both the Punjabi component in the Pakistan army and to the continuation of the military's monopoly over state power.

While President Pervez Musharraf avoided challenging the latter, since 9/11 he has quietly but systematically sought to reduce the suffocating grip of the Punjabis over the army, giving better representation to Mohajirs, Balochis, Pashtuns and even a few Sindhis in the higher reaches of both the military as well as the civil administration. Had there been a teaming up between the wily Musharraf and the mercurial Bhutto, especially after he was made to quit as army chief, the two may have succeeded in leveraging anti-army sentiment in Pakistan enough to send the soldiers back to their barracks.

Since the 1950s, those in uniform have controlled Pakistan's civilian institutions, ensuring that these were melded with the military into a seamless system of preference and privilege to a military that has made jihad a lucrative industry. Especially since anti-U.S. passions rose after the Iraq war in 2003, but dating back to the earlier attempt by Musharraf to put the Taliban out to dry in Afghanistan , the Baloch and Pashtun components of the Pakistan army turned against their chief, to be joined by the Punjabi component shortly thereafter.

While the Baloch and the Pashtun were reacting to the "retreat" from Afghanistan and the occupation of Iraq, the Punjabi component turned negative to Musharraf more than two years after the post-Saddam occupation of Iraq made the United States an object of hatred in the Muslim world. This was because, by mid-2005, they were convinced that Musharraf was seeking to eliminate their overwhelming clout in the armed forces. From that time onward, the Punjabi component silently linked hands with those elements in Pakistan's civil society that wanted Musharraf to quit as army chief.

From the end of 2003, the process of rendering ineffective the writ of Pervez Musharraf within the Pakistan army developed -- a trend that accelerated in 2005. By the end of that year, his writ had largely ceased to operate in the services, with obvious consequences for NATO's war in Afghanistan.

It is likely that it was after his backers in the Pentagon and the U.S. State Department were convinced that Musharraf had become an ineffective asset that the plan to yoke him to a civilian public figure was implemented. With characteristic disregard for the ethnic chemistry of the army, the individual chosen as the other half of this pair was Benazir Bhutto. Unfortunately for U.S. policymakers, being Sindhi, Bhutto was regarded as an outsider by the dominant Punjabi component of the Pakistan army.

Also, despite an awareness that she had the Bhutto family trait of heated rhetoric that was seldom translated into reality, her numerous public vows to eliminate the jihadis went down badly in an army that has made jihad into a profitable enterprise, whether it be the battle against the Soviets in Afghanistan or the shadow boxing against the Taliban seen since 9/11. Added to the billions in U.S. taxpayer money have been the profits from the drugs trade, which in South Asia is run out of Pakistan.

Among the voting public, Bhutto's open embrace of U.S. policies and the influence of her husband, Asif Ali Zardari, soured her appeal. By contrast, her rival Nawaz Sharif gained in popularity, having clearly gained the covert backing of the Punjabi establishment in the army, as had deposed Chief Justice Iftikhar Chowdhury when he challenged Musharraf. Sharif kept up verbal sallies against the unpopular Musharraf, a man that the Punjabi generals were delighted to see run down.

The background noise of anti-Musharraf rhetoric, coupled with more than a nudge from the White House, forced the former commando to doff his uniform and emerge in the unaccustomed role of "civilian head of state," with a Punjabi general, Ashfaq Kiyani, taking over as army chief.

Although Kiyani has the right atmospherics to please the United States -- including a clean-shaven chin and a repertoire of "anti-jihad" buzzwords -- his friends say the new chief's commitment to "winning back the strategic loss suffered in Afghanistan" is total, and therefore that he would place emphasis not on counter-insurgency operations but on the fool's errand of identifying and winning over so-called "moderate Taliban," a process tailor-made to enable the militia to recoup and regroup to a strength sufficient to launch a country-wide assault against NATO in Afghanistan by mid-2009.

Unlike the 1990s, when she helped insert the Taliban into power in Kabul, this time Bhutto seemed a genuine convert to a policy of going after the jihadis, lest they paralyze the machinery of the state with multiple attacks. She was also likely to have reinforced Musharraf's subtle moves to reduce Punjabi influence in the military, aware that she was disliked within this group, and that therefore its potential for trouble needed to be eliminated.

Small wonder that Bhutto was provided with a vehicle with a sunroof to transport her at that final rally in the Punjabi heartland, or that Inter-Services Intelligence-linked spokespersons are seeking to muddy the details of the manner in which she was taken out. Photographs that appear to show a shooter and a suicide bomber reveal that the former fitted into the close-cropped, dark-spectacled stereotype of the intelligence operative.

Although television footage showed him as well as a gun dropped on the ground after the killing, rather than seek to apprehend him, the army-controlled Pakistan administration has gone into overdrive with a theory that very conveniently places the blame on "al-Qaida."

While the suicide bomber may indeed have been linked to the Lashkar-i-Jhangvi or other presumed "al-Qaida" affiliates, it needs to be remembered that almost all these groups have close operational links to the Pakistan military, as does the head of the Intelligence Bureau, retired brigadier Ijaz Shah, who was openly accused by Benazir Bhutto of seeking to eliminate her. Although Musharraf may have wanted Shah to be replaced, since the end of 2005 he has had to cover for the Punjabi component in the army in order to retain some semblance of salience within that institution, and Shah is one of the numerous anti-Bhutto protectees of this faction.

The Punjabis within the army would like to see any sympathy wave for Bhutto's Pakistan People's Party dissipate enough to enable their nominee, Nawaz Sharif, to win the elections. Unless the Jan. 8 elections are postponed, they are unlikely to be able to damp popular pressure for a withdrawal of the army to the barracks....

The GlassHouse Blog on political and other happenings in Pakistan has an interesting backgrounder on the exile of Nawaz Sharif to Saudi Arabia, from August 17, 2007.

The Pakistani ISI has extensive history with al Qaeda and the Taliban (CIA, Saudi and UK monies and weaponry were funneled through the ISI to the Afghanis Soviet resistance in the 1980s; the former Pakistani ISI Chief General Mahmoud Ahmad had been one of the "money men" who had wired funds to the 9/11 "hijackers"). UPI reported on December 21, 2007, that the Pakistani ISI with Al-Qaeda were behind the threats to attack the Kamakhya temple and other religious places in Assam (India), and blow up the All Assam Students Union (AASU), the offices of the BJP's (Bharatiya Janata Party) Assam unit, and kill AASU adviser Samujjal Bhattacharya. It has been published (here) that the AASU is thought to have connections with RAW (the Research and Analysis Wing is India's foreign intelligence agency). India Interacts reported:

...A letter addressed to the BJP state unit president Ramen Kalita, by eight persons claiming to be ISI and al-Qaeda active members in Assam, threatened "to bomb out the main BJP and AASU offices like the World Trade Centre (in USA)".

"Your offer to (Bangladeshi writer) Taslima Nasreen to stay in Assam is against Islam and its tenets. If you don't stop your activities immediately, a powerful bomb will be exploded in your main office," cautioned the letter made available to the media on Friday.

The letter dated December 11, hand-written on plain paper in immigrant Bangladeshi style Assamese and received by post on Thursday, alleged that the BJP under Kalita's leadership was "resorting to mental and physical torture of local Muslims.

"Samujjal Bhattacharya's death is also certain for his activities as AASU advisor", the letter threatened....

Ahmed Quraishi describes the strange bedfellows the US has found for itself, and the political machinations in Pakistan, in the Great Game, for The New Times (Bangladesh), on December 12, 2007:

...it all really began almost three years ago, when, out of the blue and recycling old political arguments, Akbar Bugti launched an armed rebellion against the Pakistani state, surprising security analysts by using rockets and other military equipment that shouldn't normally be available to a smalltime village thug. Since then, Islamabad has sat on a pile of evidence that links Bugti's campaign to money and ammunition and logistical support from Afghanistan, directly aided by the Karzai administration and India, with the US turning a blind eye....

..."We have indications of Indian involvement with anti-state elements in Pakistan," declared the spokesman of the Pakistan Foreign Office in a regular briefing in October. The statement was terse and direct, and the spokesman, Tasnim Aslam, quickly moved on to other issues.

This is how a Pakistani official explained Aslam's statement: "What she was really saying is this: We know what the Indians are doing. They've sold the Americans on the idea that [the Indians] are an authority on Pakistan and can be helpful in Afghanistan. The Americans have bought the idea and are in on the plan, giving the Indians a free hand in Afghanistan. What the Americans don't know is that we, too, know the Indians very well. Better still, we know Afghanistan very well. You can't beat us at our own game."...

Larry Chin and Michel Chossudovsky both discuss the events in light of the Bhutto assassination at Global Research.

Here and here provide some history on the author Taslima Nasreen.

Note that the US sanctions on financial interactions with Iranian banks has essentially put enough pressure for India to hold up on the the Iranian LNG (liquid natural gas) pipeline project (the State Bank of India isn't transacting business with Iran). Any pipeline would necessarily have to cross Pakistan: "Pakistan could earn as much as $500 million in royalties from a transit fee and save $200 million by purchasing cheaper gas from this pipeline project." Jun Yang and Gurdeep Singh (Dow Jones Newswires, on Gulf Times) report that:

...“We can expect immediate impact for energy projects such as the Trans-Afghanistan pipeline and the Iran-Pakistan-India natural gas pipeline, which could be shelved as the government struggles to maintain internal security,” said Chietigj Bajpaee, a research analyst at London-based consultancy Global Insight....

Arnaud de Borchgrave (UPI editor at large had these interesting insights on October 25):

...Radical groups pollute Pakistan's political scene. Since Sept. 11, 2001, when Musharraf, under U.S. pressure, dumped his Taliban proteges, extremist groups, once encouraged by the all-powerful Inter-Services Intelligence agency for the "liberation" of Indian Kashmir, were ordered to shut down. Many of them had offices in the major cities that were closed only to reopen with a different name a block or two away.

The most ominous warning of all for Bhutto came from the federal railways minister, Sheik Rashid Ahmad. He accused her of "raising the flag of imperialism (i.e., Bush administration support), which means she "will have to face suicide attacks. We have already conveyed to her that the ground realities have changed(since she was last in her country eight years ago)."

This perennial Cabinet minister ran a jihadi training camp in the 1980s. He also served in the previous military government under President Zia ul-Haq. As Musharraf's information minister, he was known as a champion spin doctor who
affects an always-in-the-know image. This time he inadvertently validated Bhutto's claim that some elements in Musharraf's government collude with militant radicals assigned to sabotage her political comeback.

Ahmad is a close friend of retired Gen. Hamid Gul, a former ISI chief who acts as strategic adviser to the Muttahida Majlis-e-Amal coalition of six politico-religious extremist parties that governs two of Pakistan's four provinces (Baluchistan and the Northwest Frontier province). Gul hates the United States -- and anything Washington favors -- with a passion. He assisted the creation of the Taliban in the early 1990s and to this day believes the Sept. 11 al-Qaida attacks were a plot engineered by Israel's Mossad, the CIA and the U.S. Air Force. ("How come no fighters were scrambled to take on the planes you say were hijacked?" he asked this reporter.)

From al-Qaida and Taliban sanctuaries in the tribal areas on the Afghan border to Karachi, a teeming port city of 15 million some 600 miles away, there are tens of thousands of fanatics who would love to see Bhutto dead....

...Despite the newly acquired accoutrements of modernity, a large part of Pakistan is still stuck in the past. More than half its 160 million people are illiterate. And aligned against Bhutto's return to power are renegade ISI cadres; the nationwide MMA coalition of extremists throughout the country; supporters of the late military dictator ul-Haq, who seized power from Bhutto's father, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, and then ordered him executed by hanging (Zia himself died in a mysterious plane crash in 1988 and Benazir became prime minister in a restored civilian government); and the countless flat-Earth clerics and their followers who regard a female leader as an abomination....

US sanctions on Iran are discussed here and here.

Abbas Maleki (director of the International Institute for Caspian Studies in Tehran and a senior research fellow at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, Iran’s deputy foreign minister from 1985 to 1997), MIT Center for International Studies, noted (on AlterNet, October 30, 2007, that the Iran-Pakistan-India pipeline project:

... is immensely important to the on-going peace process between India and Pakistan. A number of observers of the India-Pakistan conflict have termed this project as the mother of all confidence-building measures between India and Pakistan and named it the Peace Pipeline....

...the Bush administration has been trying to pressure both (India and Pakistan) to back off the deal....

...Regarding Iran and its domestic situation, historically with the exception of the IGAT-I project, under which Iran exported natural gas (via pipeline) to the former Soviet Union in the 1970s, all other projects seeking to export gas from Iran have somehow fallen victim to political conflicts....

Hassan Abbas comments on her blog (Sunday, December 18, 2005): "...Pakistan has not yet established control over the province of Balochistan and especially the Mengal-dominated Khuzdar territory through which the Iranian pipeline will pass. The last time President Musharraf showed the flag in the province by visiting the Marri-dominated Kohlu region, the visit was followed by a rocket attack on the FC helicopter carrying its IG."

Blood borders How a better Middle East would look by Ralph Peters was published in the Armed Forces Journal, in June of 2006, and presented discussion of the "new middle east" ... see the complete article (including the maps, which the Armed Forces Journal no longer keeps with the article) here on Mir Azaad's The Government of Balochistan in Exile blog (Wednesday, July 05, 2006).

Here and here are a bit of the history of the US's efforts to get a pipeline built through Afghanistan (note the participation of Enron). Note that Enron's pipeline would have traversed the Punjabi region of Pakistan.

So, there exists a government in Pakistan that has been ineffective in securing the region with the most petroleum assets (Balochistan), and through which any pipeline from Iran to India will necessarily traverse. They have been ineffective in routing the Taliban/al Qaeda forces that utilize their "northwest territory" (Pushtun and Punjabi areas). We have the Enron-Punjabi pipeline's dreams buried in Pakistan, unfulfilled. The military in Pakistan is controlled by the Punjabis, who would feel a significant reduction in power and influence and affluence should the Balochs gain their freedom from Pakistan, or if any pipeline would traverse the Balochistan region. That military's intelligence service is the connection to "al Qaeda". The ISI may have gotten inklings of some "student/student association" activities, some Indian activities, all under the nose of the US (Pakistan's sponsor), and the ISI & Al Qaeda have threatened to eliminate (murder) those Indian students & associations. Bhutto herself threatened to eliminate the "jihadists" and also to "reorganize" the Pakistani military and ISI.

It would appear that Pakistan's patron has wearied from a significant lack of results, and destabilization/regime change may be in play. What of Nawaz Sharif, and his backers - the SAUDIS? Are we seeing the beginning of the Balkanization of Pakistan ... And perhaps the most radical of thoughts .... partition dissolved ... Punjab and Sindh go back to India, Pushtun to Iran, and Balochistan is freed.